November
5, 2007
Mental
Health Weekly Article on Health Care Enhancements
for Direct Care Staff
We
have been working with Mental Health Weekly on this attached story
on Health Care Enhancements. I think the article does a good job
in talking about the disparity in health care enhancement for
direct care staff in developmental disabilities and direct care
staff in mental health.
The
principal point I was trying to make was that developmental disability
workers should get health care enhancements but how can you leave
behind direct care staff in mental health. The disparity right
now is close to $77 million dedicated in developmental disabilities
for enhancements as opposed to nothing for the program in mental
health. 77 to 0. It is time to address that disparity and provide
mental health workers with enhanced health care. If you want to
sign on to support this change, please send me an e-mail at gliebman@mhanys.org
Please
note that in the article, I should have made it clear that this
enhancement would not be limited to just direct care staff in
licensed programs. We need a broad health care enhancement for
the entire spectrum of direct care staff in all mental health
programs.
N.Y.
Advocates Push For Compensation for Direct Care Workers
Mental
Health Weekly
November 5, 2007
Citing
health care workforce concerns in the mental health community,
New York advocates are calling for increased health care enhancements
for direct care staff in the state’s mental health programs.
The
Mental Health Association in New York State (MHANYS), the New
York Association of Psychiatric Rehabilitation Services (NYAPRS)
and several other groups are requesting $10 million, which in
actual dollars, would mean a $325 per person health insurance
stipend for 31,000 direct care workers in programs licensed by
the New York State Office of Mental Health (OMH).
Currently,
the Office of Mental Retardation and Developmental Disabilities
(OMRDD) provides healthcare initiatives for its direct care workers
known as Health Care Enhancement I and II, which calls for the
agency to distribute $17 million to voluntary provider agencies.
Additionally,
OMRDD was able to draw down more than $13 million from Medicaid.
The requested $325 stipend for OMH direct care workers would provide
equitable coverage for both groups.
Officials
have indicated that the $325 per person will be used to reimburse
out of pocket expenses paid by employees; to reduce premiums paid
by employees; to set up flexible spending accounts; and to set
up health related reimbursement arrangements.
“The
health care enhancements provided to OMRDD workers should also
be provided to direct care workers with the state OMH,”
Glenn Liebman, MHANYS chief executive, told MHW. “By offering
a $325 health care incentive for direct care staff, it provides
individuals with a greater incentive for staying in their position.”
Liebman noted that the health care incentives are also consistent
with New York Gov. Eliot Spitzer’s call for universal health
care for all New Yorkers.
Invaluable
Services
“We
strongly agree that direct care staff in OMRDD deserve to have
health care enhancements, but there has to be equity with mental
health,” said Liebman. “New York State will have expended
over $70 million, including Medicaid, for health care enhancements
for OMRDD licensed workers and they have not spent one penny for
health care enhancements for OMH licensed workers.”
Liebman
added, “It makes no sense when both groups are performing
invaluable services in the community. We are asking for $325 as
a starting point but with a call for increased funding in the
future.” The retention of direct care staff is an important
issue, said Liebman.
“The
great concern we have is the rate of direct care staff who are
leaving the field,” said Liebman. Some agencies have reported
about 30 to 40 percent, he noted. “The state is being responsive
to the concerns of the turnover rate for people working in direct
care,” said Liebman.
OMH’s
priorities for 2008-2009 include securing the third year cost-of-living
for direct care workers, the Journal News reported. Liebman said
that while advocates think it is important to support the third
year of the Cost-of-Living Allowance (COLA), they think its equally
imperative that COLA be combined with health care enhancements
to retain quality staff.
“If
you combine COLA with a health care incentive, you’re sending
a strong message to the workforce in mental health: ‘We’re
a population that is invaluable,’” noted Liebman.
According
to MHANYS, many agencies in the state run both mental health and
developmental disabilities programs. They note that it creates
an inequitable work place when there are health incentives for
the developmental disabilities staff and not the mental health
staff.
Existing
Roadmap
“There’s
already an existing roadmap in place,” with the efforts
of OMRDD, he said, adding that OMH should follow OMRDD’s
successful model.
Advocates,
meanwhile, have met with the state OMH, the governor and the division
of the budget, said Liebman. “All of the meetings have been
positive,” he noted.
“We’ve
been told it’s a very tough budget year,” he said.
“We’ll continue to get the word out and send the message
to policymakers. This is a very important initiative for the mental
health community.”
Raymond
Schwartz, co-chair of public policy for NYAPRS, said that Commissioner
Michael Hogan stated that direct care worker health enhancement
would likely be provided in the state budget. “Hogan acknowledged
the importance of providing something to help providers keep staff,”
Schwartz told MHW. (NYAPRS Note clarification: Commissioner Hogan
listed the 3rd year of the CPI-adjusted workforce COLA as a priority).
“The
whole issue boils down to equity,” he noted. ‘It’s
about treating people fairly and providing them with a meaningful
packet of benefits to show you really care about them,”
said Schwartz. “Turnover is not good for anybody and it’s
not good for the people being served."
Issues
of Veterans and Mental Health
Last
week, I had the opportunity to present in forums at Nassau Community
College and at Syracuse University on issues of returning veterans
and mental health needs.
At
both forums the number one issue I heard regarding services was
the stigma associated with acknowledging mental health problems
in the military. During the Nassau forum, a Vietnam Veteran spoke
to the stigma associated with seeking services during Vietnam
and noted that the culture has not changed dramatically with the
current war in Iraq and Afghanistan. It is no wonder that less
than 30% of veterans with mental health issues seek treatment.
MHANYS,
through Deputy Director Helena Davis, is working with NASW to
develop a statewide conference on veterans needs especially around
issues of PTST and TBI. Listed below is a 12 point action plan
around veterans issues and how we can help respond to their needs.
We will be advocating with the Spitzer administration and the
legislature to implement these recommendations.
Recommendations